This is Why I Don’t Hold Stocks Through Earnings Reports
As you know I was long ADTN for a few days recently but sold it because they were due to report earnings. The reason I get out ahead of earnings is that I have no clue what the company is going to say nor, more importantly, how the market will react to what they say. ADTN is a great example today. They reported real late last night (6:39 PM), although everything I saw said they were supposed to report this morning. This morning there were what seemed to be decent comments from a couple of analysts. The stock was trading down about a dollar to $28.50 in the pre-market. But all of this is before the conference call which started at 10:30 this morning. That’s when the bottom fell out:

Of course I’ve also had situations where I got out of a stock (PLMO was a recent example) and it went in what would have been my favor. But I’ve found that it’s just a roll of the dice to stay in through earnings reports, and I don’t like gambling… I speculate!
Even once the report is out it’s often wise to wait for the conference call and then the analysts’ post-conference call comments. So I like to wait until a day or two after earnings to consider a stock. There’s enough risk in trading without adding another unknown into the mix.
Let me add that I’m pissed about RHAT! I had that short nailed a couple of weeks ago but got shaken out. Argh!!!! It’s now down 28% from where I shorted it. Frickin’, frackin’… ![]()




















This post has 4 comments
July 13th, 2004
Does this selloff qualify for your “buy a popular stock that’s temporarily oversold” dictum?
July 13th, 2004
I didn’t know that was my dictum. If I had a dictum it would be buy stocks that are in uptrends when they pullback towards the trendline and then show signs of reversing back towards the primary trend. If by ‘popular’ you mean stocks that have a good amount of volume and aren’t thinly traded then I’ll add that too. There are certainly a lot of stocks that meet that criteria right now but there are also a lot that have broken and are in downtrends.
July 14th, 2004
No “dummy” entry for RHAT today? What a stinker!
July 15th, 2004
Mike: I was oversimplifying what you’ve said before about buying a strong stock on temporary weakness … but waiting for a signal of returning to the uptrend is the key part I left out; after all, once it starts going down there’s no telling how long it’ll keep falling.